Why Most New Year’s Resolutions Fail

New Year’s resolutions list on a notepad, hinting why most New Year’s resolutions fail and how SMART goals help
What's in this Article:

If you’re anything like me, you’re wondering how on earth is it the end of December already. Yes, despite the previous 365 days, only now has this revelation occurred. For practical tips throughout the year, browse the PREKURE blog.

Of course, everything is busier than ever and our schedule is a mess, that’s just synonymous with the Christmas period. But shouldn’t we take some time for ourselves to reflect on the previous year and create some resolutions? Well, it’s estimated that more than half of all New Year’s resolutions fail, but that doesn’t have to be the case for you this time. Here’s how to identify the right resolution for you; how to create a plan and how to reach it. For general guidance on healthy change see the NHS Live Well hub, and consider PREKURE’s free Health Coaching 101 short course to build SMART goals.

Table of contents

Why most New Year’s resolutions fail

It’s estimated that more than half of all New Year’s resolutions do not last. The usual culprits are unclear motives, vague plans, no accountability and all‑or‑nothing thinking after the first slip.

Make resolutions that stick

Dream big and enjoy the journey

There’s nothing wrong with setting big, audacious New Year’s resolutions. It’s inspirational. It will give you a kick to get started. There’s just one caveat with that: don’t put your happiness on hold while you wait to achieve that goal.

For example, many of us tend to have this ongoing issue with weight. We say, “When I lose five kilos, then I’ll be happy”. What a load of rubbish.

Set your goal, make it big and go for it, but be happy in the moment and on the journey to achieving it.

Know your ‘why’

What is your ‘why’? And do you care enough about this ‘why’ to make the changes necessary and stick to it during the inevitable tough times? Only when you truly understand yourself and the ‘job to be done’ will you achieve your health goals.

To help you more fully understand your ‘why’, start by asking yourself the right questions. And that’s harder than you think. As Richard Feynman, the famous physicist, once said: “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself and you are the easiest person to fool.”

Bottom line: If you want to achieve your goals then you are going to have to truly understand yourself.

Why is this goal important to you?

Make your goal a SMART goal

SMART is an acronym for:

  • Specific
  • Measurable
  • Achievable
  • Relevant
  • Timely

Your goal is well‑defined and clear, e.g.:

“I’m going to train to do a 10km race in July.”

“I’m going to lose 5kg.”

“I’m going to reconnect with my siblings by calling them every month.”

…and not something vague about trying to eat healthier.

Set up specific criteria that measure your progress towards the goal, e.g. number of training sessions per week; weight lost each month; hours slept each night. Taking daily photos, logging progress into a journal or making notes on your phone can be helpful to track your progress.

Is this goal attainable and possible for you to achieve? Absolutely dream big, but is it reasonable to think you are going to be the same weight as you were in your 20s? Or be able to run a marathon in two months’ time? Trying to take too big a step too fast can leave you feeling frustrated.

This comes back to your ‘why’. Is this a goal that really matters to you, and are you making the resolution for the right reasons?

The timeline toward reaching your goal should be realistic too. Give yourself enough time to get to your finish line, with lots of smaller goals set up along the way.

We often over‑estimate what we can achieve in the short term, but we grossly under‑estimate what we can achieve in the long term. (Dr Louise Schofield)

Sort your support

Changing your habits, or introducing new healthy habits, is a lot easier if you have support or you get a partner, family or a friend to work towards the same goal, whether it’s eating healthier, doing more exercise or spending more time together as a family.

If you fall off, get back on the horse

We’re all human. Despite our best intentions, we all slip up sometimes. The first step is acceptance that mistakes are going to happen. But just because you make one misstep doesn’t mean that you have to make a second, or a third.

If you’ve missed a smaller goal on the way or strayed off the path you’ve set for yourself, it’s okay. Just jump back on that horse. Keep galloping forward. Don’t use it as a reason or an excuse to let yourself off and think, “I might as well give up this goal”. To err is to be human and it’s entirely normal.

Be kind to yourself

So, worst case scenario: you didn’t reach the goal you had set for yourself in your New Year’s resolution. That doesn’t mean that you failed. Don’t beat yourself up about it. We can be very harsh when we talk to ourselves. Instead of thinking, “I blew it. What’s the point now?”, be kind to yourself. Think about what you’ve learnt, give yourself credit for trying, and encourage yourself to try again. Remember, your goal doesn’t have to be a New Year’s resolution. You can start afresh anytime – how about tomorrow?

Have an awesome break. You deserve it!

Key takeaways

  • Start with your why: meaningful goals survive tough patches.
  • Make SMART your default: specific, measurable and realistic beats vague wishes.
  • Design support: partners, family and friends make change easier.
  • Expect slip‑ups: notice, normalise and restart at the very next step.
  • Enjoy the journey: do not postpone happiness until the finish line.

FAQs

What percentage of resolutions fail?

It’s estimated that more than half do not last, often because they lack a clear why, a SMART plan and support.

How do I choose the right resolution?

Start with your ‘why’ and the real job to be done, then pick one meaningful goal.

What is a SMART goal?

SMART stands for Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant and Timely.

What if I slip up?

Accept that mistakes happen, then restart at the next opportunity rather than giving up.

How do I keep momentum?

Track simple metrics, celebrate small wins and enlist a partner, family member or friend.

Should I still dream big?

Yes—set a bold goal, but enjoy the process and be happy on the journey.

Next step

Ready to turn resolution into routine? Learn practical coaching tools in the Health Coach Programme.

Dr. Louise Schofield and Sonya English smiling together at a PREKURE Health Coaching 101 Live Masterclass event.

YOU’RE INVITED TO ATTEND THE MASTERCLASS

Free Health Coaching 101 Live Masterclass

Learn the key coaching skills and foundational concepts that flip the traditional medical model – empowering you to support sustainable change and explore a rewarding career in professional health coaching. We are running both New Zealand & Australian sessions.

UKIHCA CEO Izabella Natrins talks with Dr Louise Schofield, Co-founder and CEO of PREKURE, about behaviour change and building the prevention workforce.
Smoking costs about five hours a day. Owning a dog adds an hour and a half. Prof Grant Schofield and Sam explore microlives, micromorts, brown fat and AI, with Louise on behaviour change.
Twenty honest questions about your health, values and habits to help you pause, reflect and take your next small step towards lasting change.

Download the Prospectus

Fill in the form below and we will send you a copy of the prospectus straight to your inbox

Prospectus Download

PREKURE™ icon logo – Click to return to the homepage.

Register for the Free Health Coaching 101 Webinar on the 23rd of November

Free Health Coaching 101 Webinar on the 23rd of November

Free Webinar 23rd Nov

Start Now